Liquor-of-the-month clubs

Join Our Exclusive Bourbon Club

Get access to expertly curated bottles every month!

Explore Membership
A Black Manhattan in a coupe with a dark cherry, on a walnut sideboard at home

Black Manhattan recipe: bourbon, Averna and two kinds of bitters

A Black Manhattan in a coupe with a dark cherry, on a walnut sideboard at home

Illustration — AI-generated. Not documentary photography.

The Black Manhattan makes one change to the classic Manhattan. The sweet vermouth comes out, and Averna, a Sicilian amaro, goes in. Amaro is Italian for "bitter," and it's the name for a whole family of herbal liqueurs that are bitter and sweet at the same time. Averna is one of the gentler ones, and it's dark enough to give the drink its color. What you get is a Manhattan that's darker, a little more bitter and rounder in the middle.

Bartender Todd Smith created the drink in San Francisco in 2005.

In this piece: Black Manhattan recipe · What the Averna changes · Bourbon or rye? · Why this bottle: Redwood Empire Pipe Dream 101 · Three ways to change it · Black Manhattan FAQ · More whiskey for a Manhattan

Black Manhattan recipe

Ingredients

  • 2 oz bourbon or rye whiskey
  • 1 oz Averna amaro
  • 1 dash Angostura bitters
  • 1 dash orange bitters
  • 1 brandied cherry, for garnish

Method

  1. Chill a coupe or Nick and Nora glass in the freezer, or fill it with ice water while you mix.
  2. Add the whiskey, Averna and both bitters to a mixing glass.
  3. Fill the mixing glass with ice and stir for about 30 seconds, until the outside feels cold.
  4. Empty the serving glass and strain the drink into it.
  5. Drop in the cherry.

Glass: chilled coupe or Nick and Nora. Garnish: brandied cherry. Makes one drink in about five minutes.

Stir it. Everything in the glass is spirit or liqueur, and shaking would cloud it with tiny air bubbles and chips of ice. Thirty seconds of stirring chills it and adds just enough water to round off the edges.

About that cherry: skip the neon-red jarred kind. A dark cherry packed in brandy or its own syrup, like Luxardo, matches the color of the drink and holds up to the amaro. A few drops of that syrup in the glass won't hurt anyone.

What the Averna changes

Sweet vermouth is a fortified wine flavored with botanicals. Averna is a liqueur built on a spirit base, so it's stronger and more bitter. In the glass that means more weight and a bittersweet edge, closer to an after-dinner drink than a before-dinner one. If you like an amaro after dinner, this is that idea with bourbon in it.

There's a practical upside too. Opened vermouth fades in the fridge within a few weeks. A bottle of Averna keeps on the shelf for a long time, so the Black Manhattan is the easier drink to have ready when friends show up. For the vermouth version, our classic Manhattan recipe walks through the spec.

Bourbon or rye?

Both work, and they make two different drinks. Bourbon has to be at least 51% corn, and that corn leans sweet, so a bourbon Black Manhattan comes out round and dessert-adjacent. Rye brings spice and a drier finish that cuts through the amaro.

Proof matters more than grain. At a 2-to-1 ratio with a full ounce of Averna, an 80-proof whiskey gets pushed around. Look for 90 proof or higher.

Why this bottle: Redwood Empire Pipe Dream 101

Redwood Empire Pipe Dream 101 ($50) sits between the two camps. It's a four-grain bourbon, where most bourbons use three: 73% corn, 19% rye, 5% malted barley and 3% wheat. That's enough rye to give a bourbon drinker some of what a rye drinker wants.

Redwood Empire calls it a reserve bottling of its Pipe Dream bourbon. The distillery batches it from whiskey between 5 and 15 years old and bottles it at 101 proof, a step up from the everyday 90-proof Pipe Dream. That strength is the reason it's here. A full ounce of Averna won't bury it.

The name comes from a real tree. Pipe Dream is a coast redwood in Humboldt Redwoods State Park, and the GPS coordinates are printed on the neck of the bottle.

Three ways to change it

Rye and orange

Use a straight rye, swap the Angostura for a second dash of orange bitters, and skip the cherry. Squeeze a strip of orange peel over the top so its oils land on the drink, then drop it in. Drier, brighter and less like dessert.

The halfway Manhattan

Split the modifier: ½ oz Averna and ½ oz sweet vermouth, with 2 oz whiskey and 2 dashes Angostura. This is the one to make for someone who drinks Manhattans and isn't sold on amaro yet.

Batched for a party

For eight drinks, combine 16 oz bourbon, 8 oz Averna, 8 dashes each of Angostura and orange bitters, and 5 oz water in a bottle. Chill it in the fridge for a few hours. The water stands in for the ice melt you'd get from stirring, so you can pour about 3½ oz straight into each chilled glass and add a cherry.

Black Manhattan FAQ

What's the difference between a Manhattan and a Black Manhattan?

A Manhattan uses sweet vermouth. A Black Manhattan replaces it with Averna, a dark Italian amaro, and usually adds orange bitters next to the Angostura. The result is darker and more bittersweet.

Bourbon or rye for a Black Manhattan?

Either one works. Bourbon makes it rounder and sweeter; rye makes it drier and spicier. Proof matters more than grain, so pick something at 90 proof or above.

What can I use instead of Averna?

Another dark amaro, such as Ramazzotti or Amaro Lucano. Each one changes the drink, so taste it and adjust the bitters.

Should a Black Manhattan be shaken or stirred?

Stir it. Everything in it is spirit or liqueur, so stirring chills and dilutes it without clouding it with air bubbles and ice chips.

More whiskey for a Manhattan

The rye and bourbon we'd reach for in any Manhattan, black or classic, are in the whiskey for a Manhattan collection.

And if you'd like a new bourbon to stir into one every month, the Bourbon-of-the-Month Club sends one.