Rye and Bourbon for a Manhattan

A Manhattan is two parts whiskey to one part sweet vermouth (an herbal, fortified wine), with a couple dashes of bitters. Vermouth is sweet, so the whiskey needs some backbone. Rye is the classic pick because its spice cuts through, and 90 proof or more keeps the drink from tasting watery. A high-rye bourbon works too, if bourbon is what you drink.

28 bottles in stock

Why these bottles work in a Manhattan

Redwood Empire Lost Monarch Cask Strength settles the rye-or-bourbon argument by pouring both. Redwood Empire ages a straight rye and a straight bourbon apart, then blends them 55 to 45, rye on top: spice to cut the vermouth, bourbon sweetness underneath. It's bottled uncut at 116.2 proof, so give it a longer stir than usual. The extra melt opens it up instead of watering it down.

Pursuit United Double Oaked Rye goes back into wood for a second round on French oak staves, lightly toasted and heavily charred. That double dose of oak comes out as cherry pie and brown sugar, and at 108 proof both carry straight through the vermouth. Drop in a good cocktail cherry and the garnish tastes like it belongs to the whiskey.

Redwood Empire Pipe Dream 101 is the bourbon we pour in our Black Manhattan, where amaro stands in for the vermouth and it still holds the drink together. Four grains go in (corn, rye, wheat, and malted barley), with 19% rye for spice and chai on the palate. At 101 proof it makes a classic Manhattan that runs warmer and rounder than a rye version.

Redwood Empire Devils Tower High Rye Bourbon is for the bourbon drinker who still wants a Manhattan with bite. Batch 003 is 38% rye, more than twice what a typical bourbon carries, so the spice cuts the vermouth the way a rye would while the caramel stays underneath. Straight bourbon, 99 proof.

Pursuit United Triple Mash Rye is the rye in our Manhattan recipe, and the one to hand someone who swears rye is too spicy. It blends three ryes from two states on a corn-heavy mash bill, so it drinks softer and sweeter than most. You get a round, easy Manhattan that still tastes like rye.

ASW Distillery Resurgens Rye is 100% malted rye from Atlanta. Malting means the grain is sprouted and dried before it's mashed, and it pulls rye away from pepper and toward the bakery: graham cracker and vanilla up front, chocolate-mint on the finish. Those are flavors that sit right next to sweet vermouth instead of fighting it. 90 proof.

These six are where we'd start. Going off-script? Pick a rye at 90 proof or more and you won't go far wrong anywhere on this shelf.

Want a new whiskey every month?

Start the Whiskey-of-the-Month Club