NOVEMBER BOXES SOLD OUT - ORDER NOW FOR DECEMBER CLUB DELIVERY
NOVEMBER BOXES SOLD OUT - ORDER NOW FOR DECEMBER CLUB DELIVERY


Illustration — AI-generated. Not documentary photography.
An Old Fashioned is bourbon, a little sugar, two dashes of bitters, and an orange peel. It takes about three minutes and doesn't need a shaker. It's also the easiest way to find out what a bourbon tastes like with the edges rounded off.
Most bad ones go wrong in the same place: too much sugar, or a pile of muddled fruit that turns the glass into bourbon punch. Below is the classic as we'd make it for a friend, then three variations once you've got it down.
In this piece: The Old Fashioned recipe · What actually matters · Why we pour 2XO American Oak · Three Old Fashioned variations · FAQ: Old Fashioned questions
| Makes | 1 drink |
| Prep time | 3 minutes |
| Glass | Rocks glass |
| Garnish | Orange peel |
Prefer a sugar cube? That's how the International Bartenders Association still writes it. Drop the cube in the rocks glass, soak it with the bitters and a splash of water, and muddle until it dissolves. Add the bourbon and the big cube, then stir right in the glass for 20 seconds. Same drink, one less thing to wash.
Sugar rounds off the alcohol. A quarter ounce is plenty for a bourbon around 90 proof, and if sweetness is the first thing you taste, cut it back next time.
Stirring with ice adds water, and the water matters as much as the sugar. It brings the proof down to something you can sip and lets the bourbon open up. Shaking adds too much, and the tiny air bubbles make the drink look cloudy.
One big cube melts slowly, so the last sip tastes close to the first. Regular cubes work fine. The drink just gets watery faster.
The cherry is optional. A dark, syrupy cocktail cherry is a good addition; leave the bright red ones from the sundae aisle in the fridge.
2XO American Oak is a Kentucky straight bourbon bottled at 92 proof, and the proof is the first reason we reach for it here. Sugar and melting ice both pull a bourbon down, and a bottle in the low 80s can go thin before you finish the glass. At 92 it holds.
The name stands for Two Times Oak. Blender Dixon Dedman drops chains of charred American oak inside the barrel, so the whiskey touches more new wood than a standard barrel gives it, and new charred oak is where bourbon gets its caramel and vanilla. The mash bill is 18% rye, which puts a little pepper at the finish. Two dashes of Angostura sit right on top of that. It's $50.
If you'd like to compare a few bottles, we keep the bourbons that work best in an Old Fashioned on one page, with a note on what each one brings to the glass.
Swap the simple syrup for 1 teaspoon of dark maple syrup and use 3 dashes of Angostura instead of two. Maple is thicker and sweeter than simple syrup, so a teaspoon does the job, and the extra dash of bitters keeps the drink from tasting like breakfast. Stir, strain, and garnish exactly like the classic.
Make a rich brown sugar syrup first: two parts brown sugar to one part hot water, stirred until it dissolves. Use ¼ oz of it with 2 oz bourbon, 1 dash Angostura, and 1 dash orange bitters. Stir with ice, strain over a big cube, and finish with an orange peel. The syrup brings a molasses note that white sugar can't, and it mixes in clean, so there's no gritty layer at the bottom of the glass. It keeps in the fridge for about two weeks.
Keep the bourbon at 2 oz and the sweetener at ¼ oz (the brown sugar syrup above works well), then trade the Angostura for 2 dashes of chocolate bitters and 2 dashes of black walnut bitters. Finish with an orange peel. This one drinks like the end of a long dinner, which is when we'd make it.
What's in an Old Fashioned? Whiskey (usually bourbon or rye), a small amount of sugar or syrup, Angostura bitters, and the water that comes from stirring with ice. The orange peel is the garnish, and its oils change the smell of the drink more than you'd expect.
Bourbon or rye for an Old Fashioned? Both are classic. Bourbon makes a rounder, sweeter drink and rye makes a drier, spicier one. For your first, start with a bourbon somewhere around 90 to 100 proof.
Should you muddle fruit in an Old Fashioned? You can. Plenty of bars do, especially in Wisconsin, where the house version is often brandy with muddled orange and cherry and a splash of soda. That's a different drink with its own fans. For the classic, skip the fruit and let the peel carry the orange.
What's the best bourbon for an Old Fashioned? One you'd happily drink neat, at roughly 90 to 100 proof, so it holds up to sugar and melting ice. Much higher and the drink runs hot; much lower and the bourbon fades by the bottom of the glass. Our current picks are on the Old Fashioned bourbon page.
2XO American Oak went out to Bourbon-of-the-Month Club Intro members in September 2026. For a new bottle to stir with every month, see the Bourbon club.
Copyright Pourmore, Inc. 2026
*If you have a shipping issue or delay please do not hesitate to reach out and we will do our best to address the issue.
States we cannot ship to:
AK, AR, HI, MT, UT
All subscription orders renew by default; gift products do not. Questions? Email Contact@Pourmore.com.
Orders ship in our standard shipping box. Bottles are not gift-wrapped, and orders do not arrive in the wooden box seen in some graphic displays.
PourMore relies upon a network of third party retailers, vendors, distributors, and couriers. When an order is placed it is placed with a licensed third party who fulfills the order. At no time does PourMore take title to, possession of, or inventory related to any order placed on pourmore.com. We are not a retailer.
Copyright Pourmore, Inc. 2026
*If you have a shipping issue or delay please do not hesitate to reach out and we will do our best to address the issue.
