NOVEMBER BOXES SOLD OUT - ORDER NOW FOR DECEMBER CLUB DELIVERY
NOVEMBER BOXES SOLD OUT - ORDER NOW FOR DECEMBER CLUB DELIVERY


Illustration — AI-generated. Not documentary photography.
A hot toddy is whiskey, honey, lemon and hot water in a mug. Three of those ingredients are there to support the fourth. Pick a whiskey that's too soft and four ounces of hot water wash it out, and you're left with warm lemonade that smells a little like a barrel. Pick one with some proof behind it and the drink tastes like whiskey, only warmer.
Bourbon is the usual choice, and a good one. The bottle we're featuring is an American single malt, which works every bit as well. More on that after the recipe.
In this piece: Hot toddy recipe · What a toddy needs from the whiskey · Why this bottle: a single malt finished in stout barrels · Three ways to change it · Hot toddy FAQ · More whiskey for your toddy
Glass: heatproof mug or Irish coffee glass. Garnish: lemon wheel studded with cloves, plus a cinnamon stick if you like. Makes one drink in about five minutes.
Dissolve the honey before the whiskey goes in. Cold honey sinks to the bottom of the mug and stays there, and you'll get the sweetness all at once in the last sip.
Proof matters most. A toddy is mostly water, so a whiskey bottled at 90 proof or higher keeps its flavor after the kettle has had its say. If all you have is an 80-proof bottle, use 3 oz of water instead of 4.
Then think about sweetness. Bourbon has to be at least 51% corn and aged in new charred oak by federal rule, and that fresh charred wood gives most bourbons a caramel-and-vanilla side that sits easily next to honey.
A high-rye bourbon or a straight rye brings more spice, which plays well with the cloves. Wheated bourbons drink softer. They work, but keep the water toward 3 oz.
Our pick for a toddy this winter is Virginia Distillery Co. Hardywood Gingerbread Stout Cask American Single Malt ($40). It's a whiskey, though technically a different kind from bourbon. Single malt means it's made from 100% malted barley, the same grain as a Scotch single malt, and Virginia Distillery runs it through copper pot stills built in Scotland. The distillery says it spends over five years in ex-bourbon barrels.
Then comes the finish. Hardywood Gingerbread Stout is a seasonal beer from the Hardywood Park brewery in Richmond. Virginia Distillery, in Lovingston, took barrels that had held that beer and finished its single malt in them. There's no gingerbread in the whisky itself, only time in wood that once held a gingerbread beer.
For your mug, the number that counts is 100 proof. It takes the full 4 oz of hot water and still tastes like whiskey.
One small thing to know: it comes in a 700ml bottle, a little smaller than the usual 750ml.
Two other bottles fit the same job. The Old Rasputin Stout Cask ($50) is the same idea with a different beer behind it: Virginia Distillery's single malt, finished in barrels that held North Coast Brewing's Old Rasputin imperial stout, also at 100 proof. If you want bourbon in the mug, Redwood Empire Pipe Dream 101 ($50) is a four-grain bourbon at 101 proof.
Warm 2 oz honey with 2 oz water and a sprig of rosemary until the honey melts. Take it off the heat, let it steep 10 minutes, and strain. Use ¾ oz of that syrup in place of the plain honey, with 2 oz whiskey, ½ oz lemon and 4 oz hot water. Garnish with a fresh sprig. The syrup keeps for a week in the fridge, which covers a lot of cold nights.
Split the base: 1½ oz whiskey and ½ oz tawny port. The port brings sweetness of its own, so swap the honey for ¼ oz maple syrup and keep ½ oz lemon. Top with 4 oz hot water and squeeze a wide strip of orange peel over the mug before dropping it in.
Skip the water. Heat 4 oz fresh apple cider until it steams, then pour it over 2 oz whiskey, ¼ oz honey, ¼ oz lemon and a dash of Angostura bitters. The cider already carries plenty of sugar, which is why the honey and lemon drop to a quarter ounce each. Grate a little nutmeg over the top.
One bottled at 90 proof or higher, so it still tastes like whiskey after four ounces of hot water. Bourbon is the usual pick. A 100-proof single malt like Virginia Distillery's Hardywood Gingerbread Stout Cask works just as well.
Yes, and it's one of the most common ways to make one. Bourbon's sweetness lines up with the honey. Pick one at 90 proof or more.
2 oz for a mug with 4 oz of hot water. If you'd rather pour 1½ oz, cut the water to 3 oz so the drink doesn't go thin.
Yes, brew 4 oz of black tea or a spiced herbal tea and use it in place of the water. Pull the tea bag after about three minutes so it doesn't turn bitter.
The rest of the bottles we'd put in a mug are in the whiskey for a hot toddy collection, from stout-cask and port-cask single malts to bourbon.
If you'd like a new whiskey every month, for the mug or the glass, the Whiskey-of-the-Month Club sends one.
Copyright Pourmore, Inc. 2026
*If you have a shipping issue or delay please do not hesitate to reach out and we will do our best to address the issue.
States we cannot ship to:
AK, AR, HI, MT, UT
All subscription orders renew by default; gift products do not. Questions? Email Contact@Pourmore.com.
Orders ship in our standard shipping box. Bottles are not gift-wrapped, and orders do not arrive in the wooden box seen in some graphic displays.
PourMore relies upon a network of third party retailers, vendors, distributors, and couriers. When an order is placed it is placed with a licensed third party who fulfills the order. At no time does PourMore take title to, possession of, or inventory related to any order placed on pourmore.com. We are not a retailer.
Copyright Pourmore, Inc. 2026
*If you have a shipping issue or delay please do not hesitate to reach out and we will do our best to address the issue.
