Whiskey for a Hot Toddy

A hot toddy is whiskey, hot water, honey and lemon. Bourbon works, and so do single malts finished in stout or port casks. The hot water thins the drink more than ice ever would, so a whiskey around 100 proof keeps the flavor from washing away.

18 bottles in stock

Why these bottles work in a Hot Toddy

Virginia Distillery Hardywood Gingerbread Stout Cask is the toddy bottle. It's an American single malt finished in barrels that held Hardywood's Gingerbread Stout, a Richmond holiday beer, so the warm spice a toddy wants comes along for the ride. At 100 proof it stands up to the hot water.

Virginia Distillery Goose Island Bourbon County Stout Cask is a single malt, whatever the name suggests. Bourbon County is Goose Island's barrel-aged stout, and this whisky finished in its barrels. Mocha and banana bread up front, molasses on the finish: after-dinner flavors that make this the nightcap toddy. 100 proof.

Virginia Distillery Old Rasputin Stout Cask finished in barrels from North Coast Brewing's Russian imperial stout. Almond pastry and honeycomb up front, dark chocolate behind, and that honeycomb lines up with the honey in the mug. Just six barrels made it, at 100 proof.

Virginia Distillery 7 Year Port Cask Single Barrel comes straight from barrel No. 10206 at 119.4 proof, no water added. In a toddy that strength works for you: the hot water does the cutting, and the whisky keeps its shape. Seven years old and finished in casks that held port, Portugal's sweet fortified wine, so ripe berries and red fruit come through the lemon.

Courage & Conviction Bourbon Cask is Virginia Distillery's all-Virginia single malt, aged at least four years in first-fill bourbon casks. First-fill means it's the first whisky into the barrel after the bourbon comes out, while the wood still has the most to give. Cinnamon and barrel spice on the finish, at 92 proof, make for the gentlest toddy on the shelf.

For a bourbon toddy, 2XO American Oak leans sweet, and that's the point: caramel, toffee, and vanilla meet the honey halfway. Charred oak chains inside the barrel do that work, and 18% rye leaves a little pepper against the lemon. 92 proof.

These six are where we'd start. Whatever you pour, stay near 100 proof. Hot water takes more out of a whiskey than ice ever will.

Want a new whiskey every month?

Start the Whiskey-of-the-Month Club