Liquor-of-the-month clubs

Join Our Exclusive Bourbon Club

Get access to expertly curated bottles every month!

Explore Membership
A margarita on ice with a salt rim and a lime wheel, on a patio table with fresh limes

The best tequila for margaritas, plus the classic recipe

A margarita on ice with a salt rim and a lime wheel, on a patio table with fresh limes

Illustration — AI-generated. Not documentary photography.

A margarita is tequila, lime and orange liqueur, shaken hard and poured over ice. The lime should be fresh and the orange liqueur should be decent, but the tequila is what people argue about at the bar. Most of that argument comes down to a few things printed on the label, and you can learn to read them in about two minutes. Recipe first.

In this piece: Classic margarita recipe · What to look for in a margarita tequila · Why this bottle: Satryna Blanco, with Suerte as the upgrade · Three margarita variations · Margarita FAQ · More tequila for margaritas

Classic margarita recipe

Ingredients

  • 2 oz blanco tequila, 100% agave
  • 1 oz fresh lime juice
  • ¾ oz orange liqueur, such as Cointreau
  • ¼ oz agave syrup (optional)
  • Kosher salt and a lime wedge, for the rim
  • 1 lime wheel, for garnish

Method

  1. Run a lime wedge around half the rim of a rocks glass and dip that half in salt. Fill the glass with fresh ice.
  2. Add the tequila, lime juice, orange liqueur and agave syrup, if using, to a shaker.
  3. Fill the shaker with ice and shake hard for about 10 seconds.
  4. Strain into the glass over the fresh ice.
  5. Garnish with a lime wheel.

Glass: rocks glass. Garnish: salted half rim and a lime wheel. Makes one drink in about five minutes.

Salt only half the rim and every sip is your call, salted or not. Taste before you add the agave syrup: a sweeter orange liqueur may cover it, and tart limes may call for it. If you like it served up, skip the ice in the glass and strain it into a chilled coupe.

What to look for in a margarita tequila

"100% agave" on the label

Tequila labeled 100% agave (or 100% puro de agave) gets all of its sugar from the agave plant. A bottle that just says "tequila" is a mixto, which Mexican rules allow to be as little as 51% agave, with the rest from other sugars. A margarita has three ingredients, so whatever's in the tequila has nowhere to hide.

Buy 100% agave.

Blanco first

Blanco, also sold as silver or plata, goes into the bottle unaged. Nothing from a barrel stands between the agave and the lime, which is why it's the standard margarita tequila. Reposado means "rested": at least two months in oak and less than a year. It makes a rounder margarita with some barrel in it, and it's worth a try once you've got the blanco version down.

Proof

Most tequila is bottled at 80 proof, which is fine for a margarita. A higher-proof blanco keeps the agave front and center after an ounce of lime and a hard shake. It also makes a stronger drink, so pour 1½ oz instead of 2.

The NOM

Every bottle carries a NOM, a four-digit number that identifies the distillery that made it. It won't tell you how the tequila tastes. It tells you who made it, and since several brands can come out of the same distillery, it's a handy way to track down more of what you like.

Why this bottle: Satryna Blanco, with Suerte as the upgrade

Satryna Tequila Blanco ($50) clears every bar above. It's a 100% agave blanco from Jalisco at 80 proof, and Satryna says the agave is steam cooked for 24 hours. It also comes in a French glass decanter with a metal sugar-skull cap, so it's a bottle you'll leave out on the counter instead of hiding under the sink.

For the upgrade, go to Suerte Still Strength Blanco ($80). Still strength means nobody added water after distillation, so it's bottled at 104 proof instead of the usual 80. Suerte roasts the agave hearts in a brick oven for at least 56 hours, then crushes them with a tahona, a huge stone wheel. It's made at the brand's own distillery in the Jalisco highlands, NOM 1530.

In a margarita, pour 1½ oz and keep everything else the same. The agave still comes through the lime.

Another good blanco for the job is El Cristiano Silver ($50), a 100% agave tequila from Arandas in the Jalisco highlands, made from agave at least six years old, at 80 proof.

Three margarita variations

Jalapeño margarita

Muddle two thin coins of jalapeño in the bottom of your shaker. Add 2 oz blanco, 1 oz lime and ¾ oz orange liqueur, shake with ice, and pour through a fine strainer over fresh ice so the seeds stay behind. Mix a pinch of chili powder into the salt for the rim. Want it hotter? Add a third coin.

Mango margarita

Shake 1¾ oz blanco, ¾ oz mango purée, ¾ oz lime, ½ oz orange liqueur and a small pinch of salt with ice. Strain over fresh ice. With the salt already in the drink, skip the rim and garnish with a slice of mango. For heat, drop one jalapeño coin in the shaker.

Apple cider margarita

A fall version. Shake 2 oz blanco, 1½ oz fresh apple cider, ¾ oz lime, ½ oz orange liqueur and ¼ oz maple syrup with ice. Strain over fresh ice into a salt-rimmed rocks glass and fan three thin apple slices on top.

Margarita FAQ

What's the best tequila for margaritas?

A 100% agave blanco at 80 proof or higher. Our pick is Satryna Blanco at $50. For a stronger, more agave-forward drink, Suerte Still Strength comes in at 104 proof.

Should I use blanco or reposado tequila in a margarita?

Blanco for the classic, bright version, since nothing from a barrel gets between the agave and the lime. Reposado makes a rounder margarita with some oak in it. Both are right; they're different drinks.

Cointreau or triple sec?

Cointreau is a triple sec, an orange liqueur, bottled at 80 proof. Many cheaper triple secs are sweeter and lower in proof, so if you use one, skip the agave syrup and taste before adding more.

How do I make a margarita less sweet?

Leave out the agave syrup and cut the orange liqueur to ½ oz. Keep the full ounce of lime.

More tequila for margaritas

Every bottle we'd shake into a margarita is in the tequila for margaritas collection.

If you'd rather have a new tequila show up every month, the Tequila-of-the-Month Club takes care of that.