Tequila for an Old Fashioned

A tequila Old Fashioned keeps the drink's shape: a spirit, a little agave syrup, bitters and an orange peel over one big cube. Swap in tequila and you want some time in oak, to do the job bourbon's barrel usually does while the agave still comes through. Reposado means "rested," at least two months in oak and less than a year. Añejo means "aged," a year or more. Either one works, and our recipe starts with a reposado.

7 bottles in stock

Why these bottles work in an Old Fashioned

Puntagave Double Barrel Añejo, Ceramic Edition makes the tequila Old Fashioned closest to the bourbon one. It spends about two years in oak: the first in used American oak, the second split between new American and new French oak before the halves are married back together. 82 proof, in a ceramic bottle covered in art by the Mexican artist COCOLVU.

Butterfly Cannon The Winged King Reposado spends at least eight months in ex-bourbon American oak, so it's halfway to a whiskey Old Fashioned before the bitters go in. Vanilla, cloves, cinnamon, and caramel line up right behind the orange peel. 80 proof.

Loca Loka Reposado is the tequila in our recipe. The agave comes from Los Altos, the Jalisco highlands, and is six years or older at harvest. It cooks in brick ovens, then rests in French and American oak for under a year: agave up front, with just enough barrel to stand in for bourbon. 80 proof.

Flecha Azul Añejo Cristalino spends 18 months in ex-bourbon American oak, then gets filtered three times until it runs clear. That's a cristalino: aged tequila with the color stripped out and the barrel character left in. Vanilla, almond, and oak at 80 proof, an Old Fashioned that looks like water and drinks like an añejo.

Sangre de Vida Reposado is bottled at 110 proof, the ceiling Mexico's tequila standard allows. Most tequila sits at 80, so this one keeps its roasted agave, caramel, and vanilla through a long stir and all the way to the bottom of the glass. The bottle is a matte black anatomical heart.

La Sirena Reposado rests several months in white oak after its agave roasts in stone brick ovens. Seasoned oak and light vanilla are the barrel notes an Old Fashioned leans on, and the agave honey ties straight into the syrup. 80 proof, in a mermaid bottle whose gold crown is the stopper.

These six are where we'd start. Whatever you pour, use one big cube. It melts slowly enough to keep the agave in front.

Want a new tequila every month?

Start the Tequila Of The Month Club