Tequila for Margaritas

A margarita is mostly tequila and lime, with a splash of orange liqueur. Lime is loud. The tequila needs enough agave flavor to come through it. A blanco is the classic choice: unaged tequila, so what you taste is the agave plant itself. A reposado margarita is just as standard. Reposado means "rested," at least two months in oak and less than a year, and that time rounds the drink off. Either way, look for "100% agave" on the label, which means none of the sugar in the ferment came from anything else.

7 bottles in stock

Why these bottles work in Margaritas

Satryna Tequila Blanco is the first bottle we'd hand a margarita drinker. It's 100% agave, with fresh herbs, citrus, and grapefruit that meet the lime instead of fighting it. 80 proof, in a French glass decanter with a metal sugar-skull cap, so it's a gift before you wrap it.

El Cristiano Silver comes from Arandas in the Jalisco highlands, made from agave left in the ground at least six years. Older agave carries more sugar to the still, and it shows: cooked agave with an earthy, sweet edge that stays put under a full squeeze of lime. Silver is another word for blanco. 80 proof.

Suerte Still Strength Blanco is the upgrade. Nothing goes in after distilling, not even water, so it's bottled at 104 proof. The agave is roasted in a brick oven and crushed under a tahona, a huge stone wheel. Lime takes a bite out of every tequila, and this one has bite to spare.

Loca Loka Reposado rests in French and American oak for under a year, enough to round the edges without burying the agave. Pour it anywhere you'd use a blanco and the margarita comes out a shade richer. Highland agave, cooked in brick ovens, 80 proof.

Butterfly Cannon The Winged King Reposado spends at least eight months in ex-bourbon American oak, the long end for a reposado, and picks up vanilla, cloves, and cinnamon on the way. Make it a reposado margarita and that warm spice lands right on top of the lime. 80 proof.

Celosa Rose is the wild card. It's a joven, a blend of blanco and reposado, filtered clear through charcoal and then rested 28 days in French oak that once held Pinot Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon. The wine barrels leave a soft rosé color and a light cherry note, for a fruitier margarita. 80 proof.

These six are where we'd start. Whatever you pour, squeeze the lime to order. Bottled juice flattens even the best tequila.

Want a new tequila every month?

Start the Tequila Of The Month Club